Nonprofit vs. For-Profit Senior Living: The Barrington of Carmel Advantage


August 19, 2025

At The Barrington of Carmel, the motto “Our Mission in Life is You” is more than words; it’s the foundation of everything we do. Since opening in 2014, our Life Plan Community has distinguished itself by offering elegant residences, enriching amenities, compassionate care, and long-term financial security. As part of BHI Senior Living, a faith-based, nonprofit organization, The Barrington of Carmel operates with a clear commitment: reinvesting every dollar back into residents and the community.

Nonprofit vs. For-Profit: What is the Difference?

When considering senior living, families often compare nonprofit and for-profit communities. Both may offer similar housing options and levels of care, but their core purpose differs:

  • For-Profit Communities operate with the goal of generating financial returns for owners or shareholders. Decisions are often influenced by profit margins and investor expectations.
  • Nonprofit Communities, like The Barrington of Carmel, are guided by a mission of service. Our focus is on enhancing the quality of life for residents, not delivering profits to stakeholders.

This distinction affects nearly every aspect of the resident experience from staffing and programming to financial protection and community stability.

The Advantages of Nonprofit Senior Living

Nonprofit communities like The Barrington of Carmel put people before profits. Every decision is guided by resident well-being, which translates into compassionate care, vibrant community programming, and wellness initiatives that help residents thrive. Unlike for-profit providers, where financial gain can shape priorities, nonprofits are mission-driven, ensuring daily life is rooted in purpose, dignity, and meaningful connection.

As part of the BHI Senior Living family, The Barrington of Carmel is strengthened by mission-driven initiatives and a tradition of philanthropy. Nonprofits can accept charitable gifts that directly enhance resident experiences, from cultural programs to health and wellness services. Through BHI’s Good Neighbor Fund, life plan contract residents who outlive their financial resources are able to remain in their homes, providing families with peace of mind that support will always be available.

Finally, nonprofits reinvest every dollar back into their communities, creating long-term stability and trust. At The Barrington of Carmel, that means continuous improvements in amenities, staff training, and care services, along with governance that prioritizes transparency and sustainability. As a Life Plan Community, The Barrington of Carmel also offers a seamless continuum of care from Independent Living to Skilled Nursing allowing residents to stay in familiar surroundings, with trusted caregivers, even as their needs evolve.

Why This Matters for Residents and Families

Choosing the right retirement community is not just about floor plans and amenities, it is about trust, values, and peace of mind. At The Barrington of Carmel, residents enjoy a lifestyle of elegance and connection, but also the confidence of knowing they are supported by an organization dedicated to their well-being.

With its mission-driven philosophy, reinvestment into quality programs, and a strong commitment to compassionate care, The Barrington of Carmel offers more than senior living, it provides a secure, enriching, and caring place to truly call home.


Ready to Learn More?

If you are interested in learning more about The Barrington of Carmel or would like to schedule a tour of the community, please call (317) 810-1800 or fill out the form below.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.